A Madness So Discreet

A Madness So Discreet

Book - 2015
Average Rating:
Rate this:
8
3
Near the turn of the nineteenth century, Dr. Thornhollow helps teenaged Grace Mae escape from the Boston asylum where she was sent after becoming pregnant by rape, and takes her to Ohio where they put her intelligence and remarkable memory to use in trying to catch murderers.
Publisher: New York, NY :, Katherine Tegen Books,, [2015]
Edition: First edition
Copyright Date: ♭2015
ISBN: 9780062320865
0062320866
Characteristics: 376 pages

Opinion

From the critics


Community Activity

Comment

Add a Comment

r
RebelBelle13
May 21, 2018

Insane asylum, late 1800s, Boston, as seen through the eyes of an inmate who is troubled, yet not insane. She escapes and makes a new life for herself through a Sherlock Holmes type character, looking for his Watson. I know this book is not for everyone, as evidenced by the wide disparity in reviews and ratings, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. This novel is part asylum, part crime solving, and part murder trial. It does feel strange putting those three types of storylines together, but here, they make sense. I almost wish McGinnis made this a trilogy- with each book getting its own focus as Grace Mae recovers from her ordeal. I got the feeling that there wasn't enough in each section- not enough of the asylum, of the detective work, and a very rushed trial at the end without much detail. I would also like to see more of Grace and the Doctor in the future, of them solving crimes and a possible romance forming between them. As it stands, there is no romance in this book, which is in itself refreshing, yet it still came across as wanting, probably because as YA readers we're so used to romance being shoehorned into every story, even where it doesn't belong.
This book isn't for the faint of heart- it is dark and deals with incest, violence and murder- so reader, beware. That being said, Grace is a strong-willed, brave, intelligent and driven main character, the likes of which you don't see very often. She's the one who makes the novel work. If Grace had been meek and mild, the story would not have been believable and she probably wouldn't have made it out of the asylum to begin with.
This certainly isn't a story to raise your spirits, but it is haunting, dark, intelligent, and engaging- something you really need to be in the mood for before diving in.

c
ClosetHobbit
Sep 30, 2017

SPOILER WARNING! Do NOT continue reading if you don't want this book to be spoiled for you.

.................

I liked the concept of this book -- a "mad" girl who escapes a horrible asylum with the help of a doctor, and becomes his assistant in solving murder cases. And it was excellent and well written for most of the book. Where it started to go south was when Grace found and dispatched of the serial killer on her own. Of course the conclusion can only be rapid from that point, but to cram a large part of the story line -- Grace's father's fate -- into the last few pages degraded the quality of writing and plot.

Speaking of the trial, it was improbable that the Senator would be convicted of the murders the serial killer was responsible for when there was little if any evidence (as is repeatedly said by Thornhollow) connecting him to them. So how was the trial was given the go-ahead? It's also ironic that the word of a mad girl turns the tide of the trial to convicting the Senator of the murders when Grace later tells him that nobody would believe someone who was declared insane (as the Senator is by the word of Thornhollow). Next, I'm not entirely happy that the murders of another were pinned on an innocent (in this regard) man. Certainly he was guilty for abuse and rape; with the number of people Grace found that he did it to, that could have resulted in a trial in and of itself.

Another issue the book has is inconsistent morality, which I think the author made a point of as a dilemma with some of her characters, but which also played out in other ways. For e.g., Nell taking "revenge" on her beau by sleeping with and infecting the rest of his male family members with a fatal disease, and the nurse and girls agreeing with her actions; there is no counterpoint to it, even though what Nell did was terrible -- we would react (and rightly so) less favourably if it was a man who did that. Other examples: the serial killer being good in some ways (by treating people for their illnesses for free) but obviously bad in others (murdering and raping women); Grace removing herself emotionally from the situation so she could murder the serial killer, just as her father did when molesting her. I think what bothers me is that the consequences do not match up with the actions of the character, or they didn't understand the consequences when they should have.

Couple last notes. With the content, this book is obviously for an older audience. Second, the way the author left the ending makes me think there could be a follow-up book.

m
mlinard
Jun 17, 2017

Great read! For mature young adults and adults alike. I enjoyed the content and the story. Am looking forward to reading more from this author.

p
PaulaSuzanneLee
May 07, 2017

Loved this book! Does not read like a Young Adult book at all. Content is definitely for older kids. While reading this book, had to look up insane asylums in the 1800's as well as treatment of patients. Interesting and intriguing read.

p
PinesandPrejudice
Jan 19, 2017

This was such a fascinating read. I found the subject matter wonderful, the whole plot line, setting and characters were different and abnormal for YA which was refreshing. It had a dark subject matter and was hard to get into at first but it was honest and interesting and unique. Quite good and worth a read.

ArapahoeLesley Nov 23, 2016

I really liked McGinnis' other books and she's a great writer. Her style is great and to read her feels natural, not forced at all like a lot of ya but this book just didn't do it for me. Starting off dark harsh and brutal yet compelling, this story becomes one of generic crime solving and convenient revenge. The characters are great though, especially string which is why this book gets 3 stars.

CMLReads_Kristin May 20, 2016

I loved SOOOOO many things about this book: the historical description of women's issues and insane asylums; the strong, complex, and flawed characters; and the murder mystery. Very well done...and with an author's note about basis for the Ohio asylum in which the story was set. Good on audio.

a
AuntieAnne
Jan 15, 2016

Excellent, excellent book. I loved it so much that I am buying the book to add to my permanent library. A real eye-opener as to how "mental health issues" were once dealt with.

Age Suitability

Add Age Suitability

r
RebelBelle13
May 21, 2018

RebelBelle13 thinks this title is suitable for 16 years and over

m
mlinard
Jun 17, 2017

mlinard thinks this title is suitable for 16 years and over

m
mauve_swan_39
May 28, 2017

mauve_swan_39 thinks this title is suitable for 16 years and over

Summary

Add a Summary

There are no summaries for this title yet.

Notices

Add Notices

There are no notices for this title yet.

Quotes

Add a Quote

There are no quotes for this title yet.

Explore Further

Browse by Call Number

Subject Headings

  Loading...

Find it at PEPL

  Loading...
[]
[]
To Top